Electric car review from 1959: A snapshot of EV enthusiasm decades before Tesla – Green Car Reports

The electrical automotive wasn’t invented by Tesla with its Roadster, or by GM with the EV1. It goes again greater than a century, with an extended listing of hopefuls hindered from widespread manufacturing by an advanced however acquainted set of things. 

The 1959 Charles City-About was a type of hopefuls. Whereas mass-production commitments from Tesla, Nissan, Volkswagen and lots of different automakers usher the electrical automobile into the mainstream, the assessment of a prototype City-About from greater than 60 years in the past—revived from the archives of Motor Development final week—serves as a cautionary word that electric-car enthusiasm has by no means been the lacking piece. 

The City-About was conceived throughout considered one of a number of surges of curiosity in EVs—this one within the 1950s and simply after a interval of speedy progress in battery know-how. It’s the identical interval that additionally birthed the Henney Kilowatt, which we reported on final yr. However it’s additionally the identical time engine displacements began to soar, the horsepower race was properly underway, and considerations about gasoline consumption principally went to the wayside. 

1960 Henney Kilowatt [for sale on Hemmings]

The City-About electrical coupe was manufactured by Stinson Plane Instrument & Engineering, of San Diego, California, and was constructed on a light-weight aluminum body from Alcoa, with two integral roll hoops and a fiberglass physique. Though by no means associated to the Volkswagen Karmann-Ghia, the sporty-looking coupe had a likeness and its “Americanized” VW-type suspension, based on MT. 

Reviewer Bob Rolofson, a racer who had pushed all types of efficiency automobiles of the period, wrote that he “turned fairly enthusiastic” whereas testing the City-About, calling it “a very new and fashionable electrical automotive.”

Listed here are some issues he stated that sound fairly near what we would write about at this time’s EVs:

Highway noise was extra noticeable. “The prototype makes no noise, besides within the cab, which has not been soundproofed,” Rolofson famous. This intently echoes one thing GCR and lots of engineers have identified for years—that the near-silence of an all-electric propulsion system doesn’t masks street noise (and wind noise).

The simplicity of the driving expertise is a plus. The check automotive has a 6:1 fixed-gear discount system however the manufacturing mannequin was to have a two-speed transmission (low and cruising speeds); reverse was engaged just by turning the ignition key in the other way. At a time when some automobiles had guide chokes and lacked synchros for his or her gears, it was refreshingly easy—because it stays at this time.

2020 Tesla Mannequin 3

It might cost in a single day and canopy the standard American commute. The City-About got here with its personal charger that “routinely units its personal cost fee based on the situation of the batteries,” taking about 7 hours. And totally charged, it could cowl about 77 miles—then and now, loads of wiggle room for many commutes. “For metropolis dwellers, the City-About will actually be the reply to low cost, sturdy, second automotive transportation,” Rolofson wrote.

Public charging was a piece in progress. “West Coast car parking zone moguls have been approached (and are enthusiastic) with the concept of putting in ‘cost meters,’ which might cost City-Abouts whereas house owners have been buying or working on the workplace.” Sound acquainted?

There was proof of pent-up demand, however a worth pinch. The reviewer notes opening the mail of Stinson’s president and noting the surge of curiosity, together with “a pile of four-digit licensed checks from energy and light-weight corporations ordering automobiles for trial.” In response to Client Information, Stinson set a retail worth for the manufacturing automotive of $2,895—roughly $25,500 in at this time’s cash, and roughly 50% greater than inexpensive entry-level gasoline automobiles of the time. The clincher was doubtless the costly batteries which may have wanted substitute after two years—erasing any probability of penciling out versus low cost gasoline. At this time, with million-mile batteries on the horizon and battery costs falling quickly, these considerations are fading quick.

Wallbox Quasar, for bi-directional DC charging

And listed here are some impressions or stereotypes which can be dated and easily not legitimate in fashionable electrical automobiles: 

A backseat of batteries. The batteries (described solely as selenium, however doubtless of the lead-acid selection) stuffed up a lot of the realm that will have been the rear seat—and skewing 65 p.c of the automotive’s 1,800 kilos on the rear wheels—with the reviewer noting that the manufacturing model would have leap seats over the battery field. This serves as a reminder of how far volumetric vitality density of batteries has are available current a long time—and even prior to now few years. 

EVs are quiet however not fast. The upper energy and dramatic off-the-line torque of contemporary electrical automobiles isn’t one thing that’s been the case all alongside. With two 3.2-horsepower electrical motors, the City-About had a prime pace of simply 58 mph. Whereas Rolofson notes that acceleration was a bit jerky with a short lived accelerator-rheostat within the check automotive, he might have missed declaring that relative even to the VW Beetle of the time (and its near-30-second 0-60 mph time) it was actually fairly sluggish. 

2020 Porsche Taycan Turbo first drive

Security in bumpers. The one point out of security right here, aside from the roll hoops, pertains to the bumpers. The City-About has massive metal bumpers and overriders “within the curiosity of security in heavy site visitors,” the reviewer states. There’s no point out of collision considerations of any sort, and this was six years earlier than the publication of “Unsafe at Any Velocity”—and earlier than considerations about battery shorts and fires. Gasoline was seen because the far better danger, because it ought to.

The place’s the scent? Drivers of that period have been accustomed to various quantities of gasoline and exhaust fumes—not simply when cold-starting however all through the driving expertise. It was noteworthy there was “completely no odor” in driving the EV; however truthfully, anybody transferring from a contemporary gasoline automobile most likely isn’t going to fixate on (and even discover) this level at this time. At this time’s parallel—even when charging at gasoline stations turns into extra widespread—will not be having fingers that scent like gasoline. 

What do these factors inform us concerning the current and the longer term? For starters, EVs face a few of the similar obstacles at this time as they did greater than a half-century in the past. However the numbers—for batteries, for efficiency, and for worth and operating prices, amongst many particulars—have lastly flipped the attainable future to a sure one.

Let’s block adverts! (Why?)