Fifty years in the past, nothing screamed “household automobile” like an extended, low station wagon plastered with fake-wood siding. However then the look fell out of favor and carmakers largely stopped constructing them for the U.S. Effectively, the station wagon is again, solely now it is standing on tiptoe and we name it a crossover.
Tall is the brand new regular. People purchased roughly 8.5 million SUVs in 2019, making it by far the most important single automobile class. Some 2.9 million of these had been compact crossovers from mainstream producers, and no surprise: They’re moderately priced and good for nearly each home process, from the dreaded household street journey to a weekend House Depot run. There is a cause why there are actually 16 autos within the phase, and that is cause sufficient to kind out one of the best from the remaining.
We assembled our 5 top-ranked compact crossovers, which we had not beforehand reviewed en masse. Then we added the all-new Ford Escape to see if it would shake up the established order. We structured the check to expertise this fleet as any household would possibly. And we resisted any whining from Automotive and Driver relations who’d hoped to make use of this comparo as an excuse to flee the workplace for a quasi-exotic locale. We stayed native, driving on acquainted roads the place we stay and work. We drove stretches of close by Interstate 94 to get a way of how these trendy station wagons would behave on journeys. Then we hit our favourite two-lane loop trying to find glimmers of inspiration behind the wheel.
We ran laps by the large little metropolis of Ann Arbor, too, bumping throughout its chunky downtown pavement and squeezing by its slim facet streets whereas dodging buses, rubbish vehicles, and College of Michigan college students extra engaged with their telephones than their environment. We maneuvered into and out of parking spots on the native Complete Meals lot. After which we spent a day within the C/D storage, flipping rear seats up and down and stuffing the autos with editors and strollers, golf golf equipment and baby seats, and enormous bins as a result of, nicely, that is what you do with these workhorses.
Since we wished the result to be as household pleasant (learn: financially accountable) as doable, we requested the producers on the invite checklist to produce base engines and all-wheel drive. Whereas there was some variance between trims, the autos that arrived had been outfitted equally sufficient for us to attract strong comparisons.
To gauge this class, we began with the present chief, the 10Finest-winning Mazda CX-5—this one in Grand Touring trim. In opposition to it we pitched a Honda CR-V in Touring spec, a Subaru Forester Restricted, a Toyota RAV4 Restricted, a Volkswagen Tiguan SEL, and the Escape SE. A scan of the specs chart reveals how shut this group is in each attribute from horsepower to inside room.
Conducting this comparability compelled us to beat some dysfunction. Not inside the C/D household. We, ahem, by no means argue. No, it was a sequence of occasions out of our management: An underbody panel tearing free on the CX-5 compelled a mid-test restore, a gasoline station ran out of gasoline simply as we confirmed up, and the RAV4’s logbook mysteriously disappeared for a couple of week. And perhaps we needed to therapeutic massage a bruised ego or two when sure editors did not see the ending order they wished. However we labored by the powerful stuff as a result of that is what households do.
sixth Place:
Ford Escape
Highs: Finest in braking, cornering, and noticed gasoline economic system.
Lows: Low-cost-looking inside supplies; an engine so boomy, it makes you would like for earplugs.
Verdict: Feels as if it had been constructed to a worth, fairly than to impress.
The Escape SE wasn’t as completely outfitted as the opposite autos on this check—the next-step-up SEL trim would have been extra acceptable—however that is not what landed it within the basement. Nor did its preproduction standing have any impact on its rating. The Ford simply does not possess the all-around goodness required to shoulder its method into the highest 5.
On this gifted group, all the pieces counts, and the Escape’s inside design and supplies are uninspired and inconsistent. Some areas, such because the instrument panel and tablet-style infotainment display, appear to be high-quality items, however others come off as chintzy: The door-trim panels are spare, laborious plastic surfaces abound, and even the gauges look low-cost.
That preliminary impression is matched by the best way the Escape drives. Its steering is sharp, however its dealing with is loose-limbed fairly than exact. And its experience will get bouncy on sine-wave roads.
However the Escape’s engine, the one three-cylinder within the group, is the large offender right here. On the town, the Escape’s transmission insists on upshifting early, dropping the revs to about 1500 rpm. There, the engine booms so obnoxiously that you simply’d swear you had been being tailed by a low-flying chopper. Stepping off from stoplights, there’s an odd surge. “Fairly saggy and laggy at low speeds,” reported employees editor Annie White. We did discover a workaround, although: Toggling the drive-mode selector to Sport retains the engine above 2000 rpm or so, the place it modifications character fully—go determine—and emits a wealthy V-6-like snort.
Sadly, the Escape doesn’t make up for its deficiencies with superior utility. Seating three throughout in any of those autos is a squeeze, if not downright uncomfortable. Whereas the Ford’s rear-seat kneeroom is first rate for a pair of six-footers, it holds the least cargo of the group. Solely eight of our check bins, that are the dimensions of airline carry-on baggage, match with the rear seats up; 21 with them folded. The next trim degree would not have modified this.
The Escape is house to 1 world-class function, although: its console-mounted rotary shift knob. Its stunning look and expensively damped motion can be acceptable in a Mercedes-Benz S-class. If solely the remainder of the automobile had been that spectacular.
fifth Place:
Subaru Forester
Highs: Sufficient room for a household reunion, soft experience, well-appointed cabin.
Lows: Edgy energy supply on the town, driver engagement not on the menu.
Verdict: A tasty dish for individuals who don’t love their meals or their vehicles spicy.
The Forester is sweet. It’s succesful, comfy, handsomely appointed, simple to drive, nicely constructed, and really sensible. Which may sound like excessive reward for the automobile that got here in fifth, however it illustrates the energy on the backside of the check.
This SUV is one to contemplate if roominess is a precedence. It leads the pack with 59 cubic ft of house for entrance passengers. And within the rear, employees editor Connor Hoffman—who stands six ft, seven and three-quarter inches tall—suits comfortably behind a six-foot driver. Plus, the Forester has essentially the most glass space on this group, which contributes to the sense of roominess and makes maneuvering into and out of a decent parking spot a cinch. The massive windshield affords a panoramic view, and the low cowl and instrument panel make it really feel extra such as you’re driving a automobile than a tallish SUV. The hatch opening is broad, too, and the cargo space holds loads of bins: 11 with the rear seat up and 23 with it down.
This can be a very sensible household hauler, however the Subaru is just not the go-to if you happen to’re hoping for a little bit driving spice together with your utility. Throttle response is jumpy on the town and sleepy elsewhere; the engine can sound labored. The steering is slow-witted, the dealing with relaxed, and the experience soft. “It is very remoted,” assistant videographer Brad Fick stated. “Many individuals can be proud of that.”
“The Forester is nearly fully devoid of character,” stated Annie White, who likened driving it “to consuming a Saltine cracker.” Lots of people really like Saltine crackers, although. Which is why we expect loads of customers on this phase can be completely satisfied to park this compact crossover of their driveway.
4th Place:
Toyota RAV4
Highs: Refined street manners, chunky off-roady appears.
Lows: Grating engine be aware, what’s with the faux-leather seats at this worth?
Verdict: Tries laborious to be all issues to all patrons and largely succeeds.
The RAV4’s $40,785 as-tested worth, the very best right here by far, labored towards it. So did its engine. Drop all the way down to the XLE Premium mannequin and also you’d save a number of thousand {dollars} and quit navigation and some niceties like ventilated entrance seats, heated rear seats, and a panoramic sunroof. However there’s nothing you are able to do concerning the engine—until you go for the quieter hybrid powertrain. Everybody who drove this virtually luxurious model of the RAV4 complained about its powerplant’s coarseness: Even when accelerating reasonably, the four-cylinder squawks like a homicide of crows. And for all of the underhood commotion, the Toyota’s 8.2-second 60-mph time is merely common for the group.
In any other case, the RAV4 is affable and accommodating. It gives a well-sorted chassis that delivers taut experience motions together with good-enough dealing with chops that encourage hustling it on two-lanes. Inside, the seats are cozy and big-guy Hoffman may sit within the again with out a lot bother. Oddly, a rear-facing baby seat is a decent match: We needed to transfer the entrance passenger’s chair ahead a bit to clip it into place. What’s extra, cargo room is solidly midpack.
The Restricted trim tries laborious to really feel luxurious. Seemingly each floor of our check automobile is roofed in the identical show-the-dirt, softly padded, French-seamed leatherette. “I might be aggravated if my child spilled one thing in right here,” govt editor Ryan White stated.
“It appears a little bit dated,” stated street check editor Becca Hackett. That is significantly true of the infotainment system and its low-resolution graphics. At the least the audio system gives good sound and has each a quantity and a tuning knob.
In the long run, although, it was the Toyota’s extra partaking driving character that enabled it to nostril forward of the Subaru in a photograph end.
third Place:
Honda CR-V
Highs: Intelligent storage, roomy cabin, strong driving dynamics.
Lows: Quickest however does not really feel it, inside lacks deluxe supplies, dated infotainment.
Verdict: A extremely adaptable device with strong engineering and considerate options.
Honda is just not into change for change’s sake. The present CR-V advanced solely modestly from the final technology, so it is conservative in each its design and execution. “Climbing into the CR-V is like stepping into any Honda,” Hoffman stated. In different phrases, it has the fundamentals proper however does not brag.
These necessities start with comfy seats and beneficiant second-row kneeroom. A baby seat is a simple match. The CR-V additionally accommodates essentially the most bins with the rear seats folded. The cargo flooring has two positions, the upper of which allows a flat load flooring from the liftgate opening to the entrance seatbacks (as soon as you’ve got folded the second row, in fact). The middle console has plenty of cupboard space and may be configured a number of alternative ways to finest deal with your stuff.
The inside’s atmosphere does not fairly match its practicality, although. The supplies are good-looking however removed from upscale, and the design is just not bleeding-edge trendy. The tablet-like center-stack display comprises Honda’s last-generation infotainment system. It is fussy and lacks a tuning knob, and the navigation show is small. Plus, the mechanical shifter protruding from the dashboard clacks inexpensively.
However the CR-V is a strong driver. Its 60-mph time of seven.6 seconds is the quickest of the group, however it does not really feel it, due a minimum of partially to the slushy response of its CVT. “I used to be stunned to see it had 190 horsepower,” stated Annie White. “It feels sluggish getting in control.” Bursts of throttle additionally lead to some moaning beneath the hood earlier than the engine settles all the way down to a quiet cruise.
In any other case, the CR-V is a assured, succesful over-the-road machine with direct steering and well-damped physique motions. It is rife with good qualities, which makes it really feel like a trusted good friend. It is simply that the 2 crossovers that completed forward of it have these qualities, too, plus a giant dollop of driver engagement, one thing the CR-V merely does not have.
2nd Place:
Volkswagen Tiguan
Highs: Go-for-it dealing with, refined engine, beneficiant cargo house.
Lows: Cabin is perhaps a little bit too minimalist for some, hits the bumps tougher than most.
Verdict: VW lastly builds a broad- attraction crossover that additionally honors the model’s sporty facet.
The Tiguan appears like a GTI for accountable adults. That is the way it managed to claw its method into second place. In fact, it is not a GTI—it is not practically as fast or as agile as its road-hugging, hot-hatch stablemate. Bodily legal guidelines have not been suspended right here. However the Tig does a commendable job of providing each utility and playfulness.
Instantly noticeable are its mild, fast steering and nimble, firmly managed chassis, which encourage you to dig into two-lanes—although it’s typically stiff-legged on uneven pavement. The engine hums expensively. It was the quietest at wide-open throttle and essentially the most refined of the group.
The Tiguan additionally lives as much as its household obligations. It has loads of rear kneeroom, and solely the CR-V hauls extra bins with the rear seat folded. The VW’s leather-covered seats are among the many firmest we have encountered in a very long time, however they’re nonetheless comfy and supportive. They’re acceptable in an inside that is so businesslike, it is virtually spartan. Even that starkness provides to the hot-hatch vibe. The infotainment display in all fairness massive and operates in an easy method, and there are quantity and tuning knobs for the audio system.
Volkswagen’s journey to understanding American tastes has been bumpy, however it’s undoubtedly on the precise street with this newest Tiguan. It is sized proper, dressed for fulfillment, and blessed with the driver-friendly DNA of the corporate’s finest vehicles. That is why it is the salutatorian of this class.
1st Place:
Mazda CX-5
Highs: Good-looking exterior, luxe inside, expertly tuned chassis and powertrain.
Lows: Worst noticed gasoline economic system, brief on rear legroom.
Verdict: As luxurious as it’s enjoyable to drive, a mix but to be equaled on this class.
As soon as once more, the 10Finest-winning CX-5 emerges on high, and as soon as once more, the story is high quality over amount. Primarily based solely on the target outcomes, the CX-5 can be useless final, however the information does not outline greatness. It is the subjective classes—its design, inside supplies, and driving character—that propel the Mazda into the winner’s circle.
The CX-5 is particular from the second you climb in. Smooth shapes, delicate brightwork, and top-grade supplies provide the sense that this crossover comes from a luxurious model fairly than a mainstream automaker. Consideration is paid to each element. The shifter strikes with costly precision, the traditional white-on-black gauge faces on the cluster are crisp, and the steering wheel is upscale. It is also the one wheel of the lot with shift paddles. The infotainment display is small, however its audio and nav features are managed by way of a pair of knobs conveniently situated on the middle console.
No automobile may win a comparability check on aesthetics alone, in fact. The CX-5 can also be good to drive—superb. Its physique motions are fastidiously honed, firmly damped over tough pavement however by no means brutal. Its steering is true and progressive. This ute strikes with stunning grace and hangs powerful even if you bend it into fast corners. Close to excellent throttle response makes it really feel extra highly effective than it’s. The Mazda is the second quickest to 60 mph on this comparatively torpid group. And it ties the RAV4 for quietest at 70 mph, registering a mere 66 decibels.
“Pushed back-to-back with the opponents, the CX-5 is a revelation,” stated Annie White. “It is lighter and nimbler than you’d anticipate.” This Mazda fetes you with a classy, partaking, and at all times enjoyable driving expertise—the type usually related to vehicles from Audi and BMW.
The one place the CX-5 does not measure up—actually—is inside house. Although the specs declare in any other case, the Mazda’s again seat feels the smallest right here. And the CX-5’s cargo maintain is common, at finest, amongst this group.
The CX-5 is just not a automobile that wows on paper however disappoints in particular person. Simply the other, actually. However nearly as good as it’s, the competitors is closing in. It gained this comparability check by a slim margin. Setting apart the Escape, every of the opposite rivals that trailed it to the end line has a trait or two—be it sportiness, roominess, cargo quantity, or function rely—that matches or betters what the CX-5 brings to the struggle. However none of them put all of it collectively in an equally compelling bundle. At the least not but. We’ll see how for much longer the CX-5 can maintain its benefit.
From the Could 2020 challenge.
Need extra Automotive and Driver?
Subscribe Now!
Let’s block adverts! (Why?)
